MAIL ORDERS: All cookie orders may be placed Wednesdays-Fridays. They will be made fresh and packaged for shipment the following Wednesday afternoon. All orders are shipped via USPS Priority Mail 2-3 day delivery. Call 262-794-3051 to place orders. 
Orders can be paid via phone (*$3 surcharge) or via PayPal invoice. Orders are not considered final until paid in full.

LOCAL ORDERS: Give us a call at 262-794-3051 to place your order 48 hours in advance by the dozen; 1 week in advance for larger, bulk orders.

Order your custom sugar cookies for any event! We are happy to accommodate any theme/design! Let us know your color scheme, theme, fave characters - and we will create custom treats for you that will wow & taste amazing!

Local Sugar Cookie orders should be placed at least 2 weeks in advance. Custom mail orders for our long distance customers can be purchased via our Etsy shop at www.Etsy.com/shop/CrumbsandArt

*Specialty Dairy Free & Low Sugar: Brown Sugar Cookies, Pecan Lace Cookies, Coconut Sugar Cookies

Custom Sugar Cookies


Gluten Free
Chocolate Chip


Cranberry White Chocolate

Chocolate Chip Sandwhich

Peanut Butter Cookies (dairy free)

Custom Cupcake Toppers

$2 per flat piece design. $3 per 3d design. Shipping costs vary.

For custom designed, edible cupcake toppers for any occasion - please visit our Contact Page & message us.

Custom Requests of any theme / design are welcomed!

There are many imitators, but none can compete! Be prepared to sink your teeth into (& fall in love with) our one-of-a-kind, Comic Con Famous, Gourmet Cookies! Made 100% from scratch; recipes developed right here by Andrea!


Mail-Order-Brides... by brides, we mean COOKIES!

Shortbread Dipped
Toffee and Chocolate

Peppermint and White Chocolate

Cranberry and Pistachio

Orange and Cranberry

Cookie Bars

  w/ chocolate chip, white chocolate & cinnamon spice

Candy Chip

  w/ oreo and m&m

Cookies Must be ordered by the dozen (12)

*Cookies flavors marked are one flavor per dozen

Up to 4 Flavors per dozen (unless marked *) $28

Shipping $9 Individually wrapped $3 per dozen Personalized Note $1

Sandwich Cookies
Red Velvet w/ Cream Cheese

Pumpkin w/ Cream Cheese

Banana w/ Cream Cheese

Chocolate Chip w/ Buttercream

Chocolate Chip w/ Chocolate

Funfetti w/ Buttercream

Spicy Machete Habanero, White Chocolate, Cinnamon

La-la-Lani Caramel Bits, Ice Cream Cone Pieces, Chocolate Chips

Magic Show Mint Chips, Marshmallow Bits, Chocolate Chips

Hardy Buddies Chex Cereal, Peanut Butter Chips, Chocolate Chips

The Timey Whimey Oatmeal, Caramel Bits, M&M, Chocolate Chips

Buffy the Cookie Slayer Oreo, Butterfinger, Chocolate Chips

Salted Margarita Lime, Salt, White Chocolate

The Last Unicorn White Chocolate, Sprinkes, Glitter

Dr. Beet Cranberries, Oatmeal, Almonds

Sexy Flexy Peanut Butter, Marshmallows, Chocolate Chips

Salty Mullikin Almonds, Dark Chocolate, Espresso

The Hammy Peanut Butter, Milk Chocolate, Bacon Bits

Bieber Fever Nutter Butter, White Chocolate

*Butter Beer Brown Butter, Heath Candy, Sea Salt

Dinolicious Rice Krispie treats, chocolate chips, peanut butter chips

Ex Husband Chocolate Chips, Chilli Powder, Hazelnuts

Double Chocolate Chip White Choclate, Milk Chocolate Chips

*Peanut Butter Peanut Butter, Chocolate Chips, peanuts

*Oatmeal Raisin Oatmeal, Cinnamon, Maple, Raisins

*Snickerdoodle Cinnamon, Sugar, Caramel Bits

*Pumpkin Delight Pumpkin, Chocolate Chips, Oatmeal

Hey Jude Butterfinger, Pretzel, Chocolate Chips

Puppy Love Butterscotch, Toffee, Salt

Tiny Dancer â€‹Pistachio, Mint, Chocolate Chips

More $ More Problems Cherry, Chocolate, almond

The Conn Man Ginger, Cinnamon, White Chocolare

Poppin Bottles in da Club Root Beer, Marshmallow, Chocolate

Snooze Chip â€‹Original Chocolate Chip