Local Bakeries


Andrea is the head creative baker & 1/2 owner of Crumby Art!

She's the person who whips up all of the deliciousness you sink your teeth into & develops all of our top secret recipes & flavor combos.

Andrea is not allowed to fraternize with the customers on Tuesdays or Thursdays because she's too busy droppin it like its hot in the kitchen.

Andrea is the hot mom and 1st lady of the blended modern Metzger family. She has 6 kids, 2 fur babies, 1 husband, and a chicken in an apple tree.

She loves convincing people to try new things! Even if you shake your head no and try to explain how apprehensive you are to try such things.. she WILL win you over to the dark side of unique, quirky flavors & blends!


After seven years of successful home baking, self taught sugar artist Natalia teamed up with wizarding baker & recipe developer, Andrea, to open their first retail bake shop. The Crumby Art Bakehouse & Cakery specializes in small batch, scratch bakery that'll take your tastebuds back to nostalgic days! Crumby Art is also well known in the Comic Con circuit; you may stumble upon their vendor booth, greeted with sweet treats and sassy cospola

Natalia has been coined "Milwaukee's Cake Boss" by the nationally syndicated NY Post, and her work & story have been featured in many publications and media outlets; including Fox 6's Real Milwaukee and Parents Magazine. Andrea is consistently conquering America with her crazy good concoctions, one cookie at a time and has gained notoriety in the Midwest press; including the Chicago Herald.

Together, Natalia & Andrea tag team the most epic, fun, and delicious creations!

Crumby Art Bakehouse is a chill place, full of fantastic personality, that offers a selection sure to fit your tastebuds. There is always a selection of sweet & savory concoctions, fromscones, cookies and cupcakes, to Gluten Free & allergy-friendly options! Free Wi-FI is available to all of our customers. Nothing pairs more perfect with web surfing then fresh, locally roasted coffee! Crumby Art is the first location to feature coffee brews by Latitude 136; freshly roasted in Genessee, WI. Our storefront has been described as a "living room coffee house", with comfortable furniture and a home-like ambience.  

The girls of Crumby Art also specialize in creating custom delectables for special events! Our customers tend to be looking for quirky, untraditional, local artistry with major wow factor!  In the event you are looking for something traditional & pretty, we can do that too! Simply give us a call to schedule a consultation- you need only bring your imagination and we will bring it to life!

Check out our "Media" tab to get up-to-date details on the fun we offer in shop & connect with us via social media and our emailed newsletter!


Natalia is creator and 1/2 owner of Crumby Art! She is a sugar artist extraordinaire, and the person you will deal with for all crazy cool cake requests and online fondant orders.

Natalia is the moderately foxy, cosplaying mom of four rather entertaining children, and a dog who thinks he's a cat. She also has a good looking, super loud & friendly husband you may see at the bakery here & there.

She gets the most excited about weird, unconventional, and super nerdy designs. Do you have a weird kid whom you don't understand? - Don't worry! Natalia's got your back!

​​Eat something creative!

Cupcake Bakery, Gluten Free Bakery options, Wedding Cake Designs, Bakery in Elm Grove, Shop small & local bakeries. 

You will become emotionally attached to every bite!